The Division of Student Life fosters student success by creating and promoting inclusive educationally purposeful services and activities within and beyond the classroom. The departmental program review process empowers departments within the Division of Student Life to critically evaluate their work and their effect on the UI student experience through a lens of continuous improvement. Leadership & Engagement (formerly the Center for Student Involvement & Leadership) engaged in a Council for the Advancement of Students in Higher Education (CAS) Standards program review in December 2018. The process included a self-assessment review by staff members in Leadership & Engagement, selection of two external reviewers, Dr. Angela Batista and Dr. Don Stansberry, and an internal reviewer, Dr. Mike Schluckebier, and meetings with staff members, stakeholders, and campus partners. Leadership & Engagement created the following action plan in response to the program review team's recommendations.

Table of contents

Recommendations:

  1. Clarify L&E's identity, purpose, and value
  2. Successfully Integrate WRAC into Leadership & Engagement While Preserving Its Mission and Impact 
  3. Assess and strengthen staffing capacity and organizational structure
  4. Improve internal collaboration and leadership cohesion
  5. Rebuild trust and strengthen organizational culture
  6. Prioritize and Strategically Focus L&E Programming
  7. Position L&E as a Central Hub for Campus Partnerships
  8. Expand and Systematize Support for Student Organizations and Student Leaders
  9. Implement a University-Wide Co-Curricular Pathways Framework
  10. Strengthen data, assessment, and continuous improvement practices
  11. Reduce Administrative Burden and Improve Operational Efficiency
  12. Leverage Technology and AI Intentionally
  13. Improve Communication Processes and Clarity

Recommendation #1: Clarify L&E's identity, purpose, and value

Establish a clear departmental identity and align mission, philosophy, learning outcomes, and priorities with Division of Student Life and institutional goals.

Critical tasks

  • Develop and approve L&E vision, mission, and value statements
  • Develop an L&E brand narrative and shared messaging framework
  • Define L&E student success philosophy and leadership development framework
  • Identify 3-5 signature student development outcomes
  • Update website and marketing materials to reflect identity and purpose
  • Integrate WRAC's mission, services, and outcomes into the broader L&E identity and brand framework

Success measures and updates

  • Mission, vision, and values approved
  • Consistent messaging used internally and externally
  • Framework approved and incorporated into planning
  • Outcomes adopted across unit
  • Updated website and materials published
  • Revised L&E identity reflects leadership, engagement, belonging, advocacy, support, and student development.
     

Recommendation #2: Successfully Integrate WRAC into Leadership & Engagement While Preserving Its Mission and Impact 

Ensure the transition of WRAC into Leadership & Engagement strengthens student support, belonging, leadership development, and campus partnerships while preserving the specialized expertise and mission of WRAC. 

Critical tasks

  • Develop WRAC integration plan 
  • Clarify roles, responsibilities, and reporting structures 
  • Align assessment and learning outcomes with L&E framework 
  • Identify collaborative programming opportunities across L&E units 
  • Evaluate impact of transition after Year 1 

Recommendation #3: Assess and strengthen staffing capacity and organizational structure

Evaluate staffing responsibilities, workloads, reporting lines, and organizational structure to strengthen capacity and improve effectiveness.

Critical tasks

  • Conduct comprehensive workload analysis across all L&E functional areas
  • Evaluate staffing needs for student organization support
  • Review and update L&E organizational chart and reporting structure
  • Define role expectations for WRAC staff
  • Develop proposal for staffing enhancements and resource allocation
  • Evaluate WRAC integration, reporting relationships, staffing needs, and resource requirements within L&E structure

Success measures and updates

  • Workload report completed
  • Staffing recommendation completed
  • Goals established for affected staff
  • Future-state organizational model completed
  • Staffing proposal submitted

Recommendation #4: Improve internal collaboration and leadership cohesion

Strengthen communication, collaboration, and alignment among L&E leaders and functional areas.

Critical tasks

  • Establish monthly L&E leadership strategy meetings
  • Develop annual shared goals across all L&E units
  • Create cross-functional project teams for major initiatives
  • Develop communication and decision-making protocols
  • Conduct annual leadership retreat focused on alignment and planning

Success measures and updates

  • Consistent monthly participation
  • Shared goals adopted
  • Increased collaboration across units
  • Protocols implemented
  • Annual action priorities established

Recommendation #5: Rebuild trust and strengthen organizational culture

Increase transparency, shared decision-making, and staff engagement to improve organizational culture

Critical tasks

  • Implement quarterly staff feedback sessions
  • Establish shared decision-making opportunities for major initiatives
  • Develop communication plan for organizational changes
  • Conduct annual culture and climate assessment

Success measures and updates

  • Increased participation and feedback
  • Staff report increased involvement
  • Timely communication of changes
  • Baseline culture measures established

Recommendation #6: Prioritize and Strategically Focus L&E Programming

Identify and invest in high-impact programs while redesigning or sunsetting programs with limited impact or alignment.

Critical tasks

  • Complete inventory of all departmental programs and services
  • Establish criteria for evaluating program impact and alignment
  • Identify annual signature programs for L&E
  • Evaluate programs for redesign, consolidation, or retirement
  • Reallocate staff and resources toward strategic priorities

Success measures and updates

  • Program inventory completed
  • Evaluation criteria approved
  • Signature programs designated
  • Portfolio recommendations completed
  • Resources aligned with priorities

Recommendation #7: Position L&E as a Central Hub for Campus Partnerships

Strengthen partnerships across academic and student support units to advance student engagement, leadership development, and belonging.

Critical tasks

  • Identify key campus and community strategic partners
  • Develop formal partnership framework and expectations
  • Integrate engagement opportunities into orientation and advising processes
  • Create partner resource toolkit and referral guide
  • Establish annual partnership summit or networking event

Success measures and updates

  • Partnership inventory completed
  • Framework adopted
  • Increased referrals and participation
  • Toolkit distributed
  • Partnership event implemented

Recommendation #8: Expand and Systematize Support for Student Organizations and Student Leaders

Build comprehensive support structures for student organizations, advisors, and student leaders to improve engagement, leadership development, and success.

Critical tasks

  • Develop comprehensive student organization advisor onboarding program
  • Create annual advisor development curriculum
  • Establish CLO leadership cohort model
  • Implement regular networking and development opportunities for student leaders
  • Develop leadership curriculum and resource library for student organizations including WRAC programs
  • Incorporate Pathways framework into CLO leadership development curriculum
  • Create reflection tools for student leaders using Engagement Record and MyPlan
  • Develop leadership milestones within student organization involvement pathways

Success measures and updates

  • Advisor onboarding launched
  • Participation rates increase
  • Cohort launched
  • Increased student leader engagement
  • Curriculum implemented

Recommendation #9: Implement a University-Wide Co-Curricular Pathways Framework

Lead the development and implementation of a university-wide co-curricular pathways framework that helps students intentionally explore, engage in, and reflect on experiences that support academic success, leadership development, belonging, and career readiness. The framework will integrate planning, engagement, and reflection practices while strengthening collaboration across academic and student support units.

Critical tasks

  • Establish governance structure and identify institutional ownership for the Co-Curricular Pathways initiative
  • Develop and launch a university-wide Co-Curricular Pathways Framework with common language, pathway categories, and student development milestones
  • Create a visual pathway model that integrates exploration, engagement, and reflection
  • Develop pathway guides connecting co-curricular experiences to academic and career goals
  • Pilot the framework with second-year students and assess effectiveness
  • Develop and launch a centralized digital hub for pathway information, resources, reflection tools, and student examples
  • Integrate pathway content into MyPlan, Engagement Record, My Career Path, and advising resources where feasible
  • Create a campus-wide reflection toolkit including prompts, templates, rubrics, and examples
  • Expand structured reflection opportunities across leadership, student organization, research, study abroad, and experiential learning programs
  • Develop faculty, advisor, and staff training on pathways, reflection, and engagement resources
  • Establish a network of pathway champions and peer ambassadors across campus
  • Create a communication strategy and toolkit targeted to different student populations and transition points
  • Assess staffing needs and develop proposal for dedicated Pathways Coordinator/FTE to support implementation and sustainability
  • Establish annual assessment and reporting process for pathway participation, engagement, and student success outcomes

Success measures and updates

  • Governance structure established
  • Framework approved and implemented
  • Visual model adopted campus-wide
  • Pathway guides published
  • Pilot evaluation completed
  • Digital hub available to students
  • Increased student use of planning and reflection tools
  • Reflection toolkit distributed
  • Increased student participation in reflection activities
  • Increased confidence and utilization by faculty and staff
  • Champion network established
  • Increased student awareness of pathways
  • Staffing proposal completed
  • Annual impact report published

Recommendation #10:Strengthen data, assessment, and continuous improvement practices

Develop a unified assessment framework and improve the use of data to demonstrate student impact.

Critical tasks

  • Develop common student learning outcomes across L&E
  • Create annual assessment calendar
  • Establish unit-wide metrics and reporting expectations
  • Develop annual impact report template
  • Develop assessment measures for co-curricular pathways participation and outcomes

Success measures and updates

  • Learning outcomes adopted
  • Calendar implemented
  • Common dashboard established
  • First annual report produced
  • Assessment measures developed
     

Recommendation #11: Reduce Administrative Burden and Improve Operational Efficiency

Streamline administrative processes, evaluate the effectiveness of Engage, and reduce barriers that limit staff capacity to support students and organizations.

Critical tasks

  • Conduct Engage user satisfaction assessment with students, advisors, and staff
  • Benchmark engagement platforms and processes at peer institutions
  • Review event approval workflows and identify redundancies
  • Develop recommendations for Engage improvements and contract planning
  • Establish service standards for event and organization approvals

Success measures and updates

  • Assessment report completed
  • Benchmarking report completed
  • Reduction in approval steps
  • Improvement plan completed
  • Published service standards and reduced processing times

Recommendation #12: Leverage Technology and AI Intentionally

Increase staff proficiency with AI and technology tools to improve efficiency, assessment, communication, and customer service.

Critical tasks

  • Create a departmental AI learning and implementation plan
  • Establish monthly AI skill-building sessions for staff
  • Pilot AI tools to support assessment and reporting processes
  • Explore chatbot and self-service support options for student organizations
  • Evaluate administrative functions suitable for automation

Success measures and updates

  • AI plan approved
  • Staff participation and utilization
  • Reduction in reporting time
  • Pilot chatbot launched
  • Automation opportunities identified

Recommendation #13: Improve Communication Processes and Clarity

Create transparent communication pathways, clarify expectations, and improve coordination between L&E, OSC, and campus partners.

Critical tasks

  • Develop communication guidelines and approval processes
  • Create communication planning templates and timelines
  • Identify communication channels beyond Engage
  • Implement project tracking for communication requests
  • Develop communication resources for campus partners and advisors

Success measures and updates

  • Guidelines distributed
  • Templates adopted
  • Expanded communication options
  • Improved project visibility
  • Partner resource toolkit completed